Meeting the challenges first year engineering graphic design pre-service teachers encounter when they read and interpret assembly drawing

AbstractIn this qualitative study, we explored the challenges first year engineering graphics and design (EGD) preserviceteachers (PSTs) encounter when they read and interpret assembly drawings (ADs). Vygotsky’s zone ofproximal development framed this study. Purposive sampling was used to generate data from twenty-one firstyear EGD PSTs using a think-aloud task and individual semi-structured interviews. We subjected the data tocontent analysis. The findings reveal that first year EGD PSTs, when they attempt to read and interpret ADs,encounter five challenges that have implications for the teaching of EGD with regard to scaffolding thedevelopment of spatial visual ability in first year EGD PSTs. Keywords: assembly drawing, engineering graphics and design, pre-service teachers, read and interpre

The views and experiences of Grade 10 Life Sciences teachers on the compulsory practical examination

With the introduction of the Life Sciences (LS) Curriculum Assessment Policy Statement (CAPS) in 2012 in South African schools, a practical examination has become compulsory in grades 10 and 11. The LS CAPS policy stipulates the types of practical work that needs to be conducted to develop specific process skills in learners. This interpretive case study explored grade 10 LS teachers’ views on practical work and their experiences of implementing the practical examination. This study was underpinned by two constructs from Rogan and Grayson’s theory of curriculum implementation, namely the profile of implementation pertaining to practical work and the capacity to innovate. Purposive and convenience sampling were used to generate data via questionnaires and individual interviews from grade 10 LS teachers at selected schools of the Umtshezi ward of Estcourt region. Grade 10 LS teachers viewed practical work as a mechanism to: promote learning, aid behaviour control in the classroom and engage learners in minds on and hands on activities. Factors such as large classes, lack of resources, time and support from school and parents contributed to grade 10 LS teachers’ negative experiences with the implementation of the practical work and the examination. The dissonance between teachers’ classroom practice, their views on practical work and the LS CAPS requirement is exposed. Subsequently the disjuncture between policy intention and practice emphasises the need for continuous teacher professional development and a supportive school ethos

Interconnectedness of technology teachers’ perceptions of the design process to learner creativity

The design process (DP) is key to technology education and is considered as synonymous with problem solving, hence it undergirds all its learning aims and objectives. The Curriculum Assessment and Policy Statement (CAPS) document envisages that the design process will promote problem solving, critical thinking and creativity in learners. However, a paucity of empirical studies within the South African context illuminates the interconnectedness of DP to problem solving, critical thinking and creativity in learners for which the CAPS policy advocates. Further, there is a need to explore the interconnectedness of teachers’ perceptions of the DP, their enactment of the DP and its impact on learner creativity. This paper reports on a study that explored that interconnectedness and addressed the following research questions: What are grade 9 technology teachers’ perceptions of the design process? How do these perceptions relate to teachers’ reported enactment of the DP and creativity in learners? The conceptual framework used to model the interconnectedness that exists between teachers’ perceptions and reported enactment of the design process is Shulman’s pedagogical content knowledge model (PCK). This interpretivist study was located in the Umlazi district of KwaZulu-Natal. A case study design was used to collect qualitative data via an open-ended questionnaire and a semi-structured interview from 30 purposively selected technology teachers. Content analysis of data was undertaken in line with the conceptual framework. Our findings reflect that teachers’ perception and reported enactment of DP and the flexibility of the learning environment have an impact on opportunities for problem solving, critical thinking and creativity in learners. Our findings raise questions about the type of professional development teachers need to enact the envisaged goals of the CAPS document in respect of the DP in technology education

Policy for Prevention of Sexual Assault on Campus: Higher Education Students’ Perspectives

Crucial to genuine transformation at higher education institutions is a commitment to eradicating sexual violence and creating safe, democratic spaces within which the institutions’ broader goals may be realised. Sexual assault is a serious concern at higher education institutions and requires a comprehensive approach to address it. The aim of this article is to elucidate students’ perspectives on the need for a separate sexual assault policy at the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN). Gaining the perspectives of students serves as a catalyst for sexual assault policy formulation and institutional development. In this article we draw on data generated within a larger project that focuses on addressing gender violence at UKZN. We report on a study which is located at a selected UKZN campus, and utilised an online survey which was distributed via a hyperlink accessed through student emails. Analysis is based on the responses of 265 undergraduate students in the School of Education. The findings suggest that higher education students view a sexual assault policy as a fundamental institutional obligation that has the potential to educate the university community about how to identify, prevent, report on and deal with sexual assault. Students suggest that the existing policy on sexual harassment is inadequate as a form of protection, poorly enforced, and has weak reporting mechanisms. They stress an urgent need for development of a specific sexual assault policy at UKZN that is widely communicated and engaged with. The development of a sexual assault policy which has significance for victims and (potential) perpetrators can be informed by considering students’ reflections on the personal, social, cultural and institutional elements that increase their vulnerability to sexual offences

The 4IR and teacher education in South Africa:

The 4IR has become an overarching framework within which education systems, including teacher education, are operating. Contingent upon the ideology of neo-liberalism, the 4IR seeks to transform societies in ways which respond to the relentless developments in technology, the Internet and digital capacities which, by design and intent, are purposed at increasing both productivity and the associated quality while at the same time reducing human intervention in the same processes. In teacher education, how we teach and train student teachers will be substantially influenced by the imperatives of the 4IR. There are multiple unresolved questions as the 4IR takes centre stage. For example, what will it mean for teaching and learning in schools that have severe technological and digital deficits; for teachers and students who have minimal technological literacies; for delivering high-quality teaching and learning; for transforming both the content and pedagogies of teacher education and, above all, for delivering socially just educational experiences for all our learners, regardless of class, race, and privilege. The discourse of the 4IR is contemporary and requires multiple perspectives to explore what it means in different contexts and settings, the understandings it engenders in people, what it implies across a wide range of educational decision-making levels, and that its fundamental assumptions cohere with national and societal assumptions about equality, equity and social justice. Multiple methodological approaches were utilised in the interrogation of the idea of the 4IR in teacher education in South Africa, including theoretical, empirical, and small-scale case studies, amongst others. The data these approaches provide are equally valued based on the purposes for which they have been derived

The 4IR and teacher education in South Africa:

The 4IR has become an overarching framework within which education systems, including teacher education, are operating. Contingent upon the ideology of neo-liberalism, the 4IR seeks to transform societies in ways which respond to the relentless developments in technology, the Internet and digital capacities which, by design and intent, are purposed at increasing both productivity and the associated quality while at the same time reducing human intervention in the same processes. In teacher education, how we teach and train student teachers will be substantially influenced by the imperatives of the 4IR. There are multiple unresolved questions as the 4IR takes centre stage. For example, what will it mean for teaching and learning in schools that have severe technological and digital deficits; for teachers and students who have minimal technological literacies; for delivering high-quality teaching and learning; for transforming both the content and pedagogies of teacher education and, above all, for delivering socially just educational experiences for all our learners, regardless of class, race, and privilege. The discourse of the 4IR is contemporary and requires multiple perspectives to explore what it means in different contexts and settings, the understandings it engenders in people, what it implies across a wide range of educational decision-making levels, and that its fundamental assumptions cohere with national and societal assumptions about equality, equity and social justice. Multiple methodological approaches were utilised in the interrogation of the idea of the 4IR in teacher education in South Africa, including theoretical, empirical, and small-scale case studies, amongst others. The data these approaches provide are equally valued based on the purposes for which they have been derived

South African Postgraduate STEM Students’ Use of Mobile Digital Technologies to Facilitate Participation and Digital Equity during the COVID-19 Pandemic

The transition to online mobile teaching and learning during the COVID-19 pandemic required more than access to mobile digital technologies, particularly in South Africa, a country trying to address the injustices and inequalities of the pre-democracy period. The argument advanced in this research is that the transition to online mobile teaching and learning could be used as leverage to promote active participation, quality inclusive learning, develop relevant and responsive content and achieve mobile digital equity. This interpretative case study was conducted at a South African teacher-training institution. The primary aim of this study is to explore the following question: How did postgraduate STEM students use mobile digital technologies to facilitate teaching and learning under COVID-19 conditions? Data was obtained from 20 purposively selected postgraduate STEM students enrolled for their Bachelor of Education honours degree. They participated in online discussion forums and maintained reflective journals. Due diligence was taken to ensure all the required ethical protocols were observed. Mishra and Koehler’s Technological Pedagogical and Content Knowledge (TPACK) model framed this study. The constructs of the model were used during the analysis of data. The findings highlight that mobile digital technologies were used for translanguaging, supporting students in developing disciplinary science understanding through exposure to practical work and linking cross-cutting concepts in STEM subjects. The findings of this study are significant as they indicate how to operationalize STEM teaching in developing countries; how to address issues of access and social justice; and how to leverage mobile technologies to improve practice in STEM subjects, post-COVID

Pre-Service Teachers’ Experience of Learning about Sustainability in Technology Education in South Africa

There have been many calls for the integration of Education for Sustainable development in the training of pre-service teachers so that they can develop sustainability action competence to address sustainability issues now and in the future in their communities. This qualitative pilot project sought to explore pre-service technology teachers’ (PSTTs) experiences of learning about sustainability in the processing of the polymers module, when they were engaged in community-based assessment tasks. Data was collated from 25 PSTTs enrolled for the processing of the polymers module using reflective diaries and semi-structured interviews. Thematic analysis revealed that PSTTs had three key experiences of learning about sustainability, making a difference, learning as hands-on, minds-on, and hearts-on and sustainable pedagogies. At a theoretical level, the findings highlight the value of adopting an ESD lens and experiential learning approach to infuse learning about sustainability when teaching technology education. Further, the findings indicate that if PSTTs are challenged to participate actively in sustainability issues in their communities, they make informed choices about their role in society as future teachers, the pedagogies they plan to adopt, and the kinds of learning they strive to promote in learners

The Enhancement of Pedagogical Capital by Civil Technology Teachers when Engaged with Practical Assessment Task: A Curriculum Transformation Legacy

Within the South African context, there are perennial curriculum reforms of technical subjects, for example civil technology, which is offered from grade 10 to 12 at secondary school level. Amidst these curriculum reforms there is a shortage of technical curriculum advisors to capacitate teachers for the implementation of the revised curricula and a paucity of studies on how to enhance pedagogical capital. This undermines teachers’ efforts in giving learners adequate industrial skills. In this conceptual study, we learn that teachers are now having autonomy to prepare, implement and assess the self-made Practical Assessment Task (PAT) without close pedagogical guidance from their stakeholders. As such, this conceptual study brings strategies that will assist teachers in maximising their pedagogical capital to cope with the recent curriculum change. This study found that indeed there are far too many expectations that civil technology teachers must accomplish before their learners can be adequately equipped with hands-on skills. A pedagogical capital framework was proposed to assist curriculum advisors and implementors to engage positively with PAT whilst upholding a global quality standard. This study recommends that the proposed framework could be applied to other technical subjects like engineering graphics and design, electrical technology and mechanical technology as they are faced with similar pedagogical challenges